The Sims re-release shows what’s wrong with big publishers and single-player games

Despite all this, The Sims is worth a look

It’s telling that in a market with too many options, I still put the effort in to get the game working, and I spent multiple evenings this week immersed in the lives of my sims.

Even after 25 years, this game is unique. It has the emergent wackiness of something like RimWorld or Dwarf Fortress, but it has a fast-acting, addictive hook and is easy to learn. There have been other games besides The Sims that are highly productive engines for original player stories, but few have achieved these heights while remaining accessible to virtually everyone.

Like so many of the best games, it’s hard to stop playing once you start. There’s always one more task you want to complete—or you’re about to walk away when something hilariously unexpected happens.

The problems I had getting The Sims to run aren’t that much worse than what I surely experienced on my PC back in 2002—it’s just that the standards are a lot higher now.

I’ve gotten $20 out of value out of the purchase, despite my gripes. But it’s not just about my experience. More broadly, The Sims deserved better. It could have had a moment back in the cultural zeitgeist, with tens of thousands of Twitch viewers.

Missed opportunities

The moment seems perfect: The world is stressful, so people want nostalgia. Cozy games are ascendant. Sandbox designs are making a comeback. The Sims slots smoothly into all of that.

But go to those Twitch streams, and you’ll see a lot of complaining about how the game didn’t really get everything it deserved and a sentiment that whatever moment EA was hoping for was undermined by this lack of commitment.

Instead, the cozy game du jour on Twitch is the Animal Crossing-like Hello Kitty Island Adventure, a former Apple Arcade exclusive that made its way to Steam recently. To be clear, I’m not knocking Hello Kitty Island Adventure; it’s a great game for fans of the modern cozy genre, and I’m delighted to see an indie studio seeing so much success.

The takeaway is that we can’t look to big publishers like EA to follow through on delivering quality single-player experiences anymore. It’s the indies that’ll carry that forward.

It’s just a bummer for fans that The Sims couldn’t have the revival moment it should have gotten.